Red Hat Virtualization vs. Citrix Hypervisor vs. Proxmox  

In today’s dynamic IT environment, virtualization is crucial in efficiently managing resources, increasing flexibility, and facilitating infrastructure management. Three well-known virtualization platforms, Red Hat Virtualization, Citrix Hypervisor, and Proxmox, offer different perspectives on virtualization, adapting to the diverse needs of organizations.   

 

Red Hat Virtualization  

Red Hat Virtualization (RHV) is a Kernel-based Virtual Machine (KVM) virtualization platform that combines community development benefits with enterprise-level functionality. RHV is open source (oVirt) and offers enterprise-level virtualization capabilities. Due to solid integration with the Red Hat ecosystem, RHV becomes a natural choice for organizations already using Red Hat technology. It supports critical virtualization workloads, including resource-intensive and mission-critical applications. Built for use in enterprise data centers, RHV can support up to 400 hosts in a single cluster, and has no upper limit on the total number of hosts it can support.

 

Main advantages of Red Hat Virtualization:  

  • Advanced options for large enterprises. RHV offers advanced features such as hot VM migration, contingency planning, and resource management, making it attractive to larger enterprises.  
  • Integration with the Red Hat Ecosystem. RHV integrates tightly with the Red Hat ecosystem, making managing IT infrastructure in environments already using Red Hat products easier.  
  • Security. RHV employs robust security features, including Red Hat Secure Virtualization (sVirt) and techniques found in Security-Enhanced Linux (SELinux).  
  • Great automation possibilities. RHV can automate processes using tools such as Red Hat Ansible, which speeds up and facilitates virtualization infrastructure management.  
  • Open Source. Although some advanced features of RHV may require the purchase of additional licenses, it is open source, which allows community development and access to the source code.  

RHV is the perfect environment for medium and large companies. RHV is open source and does not require an initial license fee. However, additional subscription fees are required for more extensive settings to provide Red Hat support, updates, patches, and technical support. There may be better solutions for small companies and individuals.  

  

Citrix Hypervisor  

Citrix Hypervisor, formerly known as XenServer, is an open-source server virtualization platform based on the Xen hypervisor. It provides a comprehensive virtualization solution, emphasizing performance, scalability, and ease of management. It is a platform dedicated to organizations focused on application and desktop virtualization, offering advanced features within Citrix solutions.    

 

Main advantages of Citrix Hypervisor:  

  • Performance. Citrix Hypervisor is renowned for its exceptional performance. It efficiently handles the demands of high-performance computing environments. Hypervisor is designed to use resources efficiently, ensuring optimal performance for virtual machines without excessive hardware demands.  
  • Advanced Application Virtualization. Citrix Hypervisor seamlessly integrates with Citrix Workspace, creating a comprehensive environment for delivering virtual applications.  
  • Accessibility. Citrix allows easy integration with existing networking and storage infrastructures.  
  • High Availability and Workload Balancing. In case of problems with one of the servers, VMs would automatically be restarted using another server (with minimal downtime). Citrix also prevents bottlenecks; in the event of a lack of resources, virtual machines are dynamically migrated to a new location within the resource pool.  
  • User-Friendly Interface. Citrix Hypervisor has a user-friendly interface that simplifies managing virtualized environments. Intuitive dashboards and tools contribute to a smoother user experience.  

A disadvantage of Citrix Hypervisor may be licensing costs for large-scale organizations. While it offers advanced features, organizations must consider the financial implications of licensing. Citrix Hypervisor is more suited to specialized applications and desktop virtualization applications. This may limit its suitability for organizations or individuals seeking a general virtualization solution.  

  

Proxmox

Proxmox Virtual Environment (Proxmox VE) is an open-source virtualization platform that combines KVM-based virtual machine virtualization and Linux Containers (LXC). Proxmox is a Debian-based Linux distribution with a modified Ubuntu LTS kernel and allows deployment and management of virtual machines and containers. Proxmox VE offers a friendly web interface that makes it easy to manage. 

 

Main advantages of Citrix Hypervisor:  

  • Open Source and Free Availability. Proxmox VE is entirely open source, making it freely available for use. This makes it an attractive solution for organizations with low budgets and private use.  
  • Integrated Virtualization Features. The platform offers integrated virtualization features based on KVM, allowing flexible deployment and management of VMs.  
  • Support for LXC Containers. Proxmox VE supports VM virtualization and LXC containers, making it flexible for organizations leveraging container technologies.  
  • Simplicity of Configuration and Management. Proxmox VE is known for its simplicity of configuration, enabling quick deployment and management of the virtualized environment with minimal effort.  
  • Community. There is a huge, active community of Proxmox users, which translates into the availability of many educational and support materials.  

Proxmox is intended for small organizations and private purposes. Proxmox VE may have a more miniature ecosystem and need more commercial support than some paid solutions. However, extensive knowledge is optional for implementation and management.  

  

In conclusion, the choice between Red Hat Virtualization, Citrix Hypervisor, and Proxmox depends on specific requirements and organizational strategies. Red Hat Virtualization, an open-source platform integrated into the Red Hat ecosystem, is a solid proposition for enterprises already leveraging these technologies. Citrix Hypervisor is well-suited for environments focused on application and desktop virtualization, especially within the context of Citrix solutions. Meanwhile, Proxmox VE, offering simplicity of configuration and container support, is an ideal solution for small enterprises and private purposes. Ultimately, the choice will depend on each organization’s specific needs and goals. 

09:55 AM, Dec 13

Author:

IT Systems Specialist at Storware

Łukasz Sroga